Chalk this DIY up to one of the most random projects we’ve ever done in the name of saving a buck.
We have two wood burning fireplaces we do not use. We could, but for a variety of reasons, we really like our forced-air gas furnace.
However, the draft from our chimneys was wreaking havoc with our heating and cooling bill. For some unknown reason neither of our fireplaces have a damper. I could stand next to the fireplace in the living room and feel the cold air pouring into the house this winter. Not good. It’s just as bad as one of my kids leaving the back door open. Except this time, I can’t yell at anyone to shut the fireplace! Kidding, I never yell. 😉
We considered getting a fireplace door or screen installed, but didn’t want to do anything permanent and we like the open look of the fireplace.
What most people seem to do in this situation is install a chimney plug or balloon. The balloon is inserted into your chimney and then you blow it up until it fits snugly in the space thereby blocking the air flow. Chimney balloons with good reviews run up to $70 each on Amazon. Here’s what one looks like:
The good news is the balloon should also be designed to shrink and burst should you accidentally light a fire in the fireplace. The fireplace gases would be able to escape thereby preventing a really dangerous situation from occurring.
My DIY chimney plug does not have this failsafe. I would need to take care to remove the plug before I move out so that someone doesn’t unknowingly start a fire in one of the fireplaces.
Among the many DIY options we found on the Internet, one involved stuffing a bag of blown-in insulation up into the chimney. Another one used rigid styrofoam insulation board cut to size and fitted into the space.
I should say at this point that I am NOT a fireplace or heating and cooling expert. Do your own research and find a solution that is safe and effective for you.
We created a hybrid solution. We did stuff something up the chimney, but it wasn’t insulation. It was all of the old throw pillows I’d been saving. I KNEW they would come in handy!
In the research we did, this solution seemed to work for other people and we figured we would try it first before buying insulation or the balloon. After all, the price was right. FREE!
You can’t use regular garbage bags for this, you need construction grade garbage bags that are tough enough to not tear when you force them up the chimney.
My husband stuffed a bag with a whole bunch of pillows and tied it up.
Now comes the dirty part. My husband basically shoved the bag of pillows as far up in the chimney as it would go – until it got stuck. This means he was standing up inside of the chimney.
I don’t know when our chimney was last cleaned or even inspected to see if it’s safe. There’s a reason why chimney sweeps recommend annual chimney cleaning! Safety goggles and old clothes were a must. My husband was covered in soot. COVERED. He wouldn’t let me take a picture of that. Party pooper.
(The wood you see stacked is for decoration only…no fire happening here.)
It’s been about a month since we did this DIY, so I don’t have any financial results to report on yet. I can tell just by standing in front of each fireplace that air is not drafting in and out any longer. The bag in the dining room fireplace has not budged, but we did have to shove the bag in the living room fireplace up once after it slipped down. So far, it is defying gravity and staying put the second time around.
I’m curious to see how this works out long term. I love a good experiment and I’m happy we saved $140. I’ll be even happier if our heating bill goes down!
P.S. Remember, I am not an expert on these things and I’m only sharing what we did, not recommending it. Please do your own research, consult the real experts and find a solution that is right for you. Thank you, thank you, thank you.