Homemade Girl Scout Cookie Thin Mint Ice Cream

If only those Girl Scout cookies weren’t SO good.

It would make it much easier to say “no” to the little girls coming around our neighborhood selling those hard-to-resist creations. In case you’re a Girl Scout with cookies and treats to sell, I haven’t said no yet!

By the way, I’ve been extremely impressed thus far with how articulate and composed these young girls have been. Even at 6 and 7 years old they are demonstrating impressive poise and responsibility.

I was not a Girl Scout. Hmm…could explain a few things. 😉

I mentioned in this post that we recently became the proud new owners of an ice cream making machine. This is my husband’s new toy and he thinks it is the niftiest piece of machinery around. You can bet he did did his research, probably made a spreadsheet listing out the specs and pros and cons of each ice cream maker available. If I have to listen to any more monologues about how easy this particular machine is to use…oh boy!

Our ice cream maker is electric and it doesn’t require salt or any actual manual labor on our part to make a delicious dessert. And I do mean delicious. Seriously, we’ve made vanilla, blueberry and Thin Mint ice cream so far and they’ve all been exceptional. Not just better than expected, but better than we can buy at the store.

The ingredient list for this recipe is simple: eggs, sugar, cream, half & half, cookies and some sort of mint flavoring.

I think next time I would add a little more flavoring and extra cookies just to make the flavor really burst off the charts. Oh, and you know there will be a next time…because we already ate all of this batch!

It’s hard to imagine buying ice cream from the store ever again. We’ve had so much fun experimenting with various ice cream recipes and have so many more we are excited to try! Oh and by “we,” I mean my husband. I’m not allowed near his new toy.

Spoiler alert: we’ve already made ice cream with another Girl Scout cookie: Samoas! That was pure happiness on a spoon. Here’s the recipe if you want to try it:

Homemade Girl Scout Cookie Thin Mint Ice Cream

2 large eggs
3/4 cup sugar
2 cups heavy or whipping cream
1 cup half & half
2.5 TBSP peppermint schnapps (or 2 tsp of mint extract)
2/3 cup Girl Scout Think Mint cookie chunks (or more depending on your preference)

Mix ingredients (except cookies) according to directions provided by your ice cream machine. Add cookies into the mixture once the ice cream has started to thicken and prior to the end of your machine’s mixing cycle (approximately 2 – 3 minutes before mixing is complete).

Use 2 tsp mint extract or if you don’t have extract on hand, you can use 2.5 or 3 TBSP of peppermint schnapps.

Wait for your ice cream machine to finish working it’s magic. Garnish with an additional cookie. Serve and enjoy! Makes approximately 1.5 quarts.

–Affiliate links included in this post.–

If you like sweet treats, we have a lot in common! Here are some of my favorites!

Would I Make it Again?: Apple Fritter Muffins

Whiskey Cake

Cinnamon Sugar Pizza Sticks

Danish Pear Pie

Share this:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.